….AND HOW LAMBETH LABOUR LITERALLY COOKED THE BOOKS

A claim by Herne Hill Labour in an election leaflet that last year Lambeth “issued more items in our libraries than ever before” is… pure fiction.

Libraries campaigner Aran Lewis made a Freedom of Information Act request to Lambeth council for figures for loans of library stock back on April 3rd and was supposed to get an answer on May 1st – two days before the council elections.

Lambeth’s reply finally arrived on May 11th – even after Aran had contacted Lambeth’s FOI team and asked them: “Can you either supply the information I have requested, or explain why it has taken so long.

“The data has already been given to Lambeth Labour, as demonstrated by their statement; all you have to do is pass it on to me. “Even if you need to obtain the data again, it is a quick and simple search on the council’s library management system.”

When Lambeth’s FOI department did supply the figures they only dated back to 2012-13. Figures from CIPFA and Lambeth council show that there were 835,419 issues back in 2005-06. Numbers fell to 629,119 in 2013-14, were 746,548 in 2015-16, falling to 681,882 in 2016-17 before rising last year to 744,978.

Figures obtained by News From Crystal Palace for the ten ‘libraries’ show issues and renewals April 2017 to March 2018; Issues and renewals April 2016 to March 2017 and percentage difference plus or minus

Brixton 150,147 / 133,680 / 12.32

Carnegie 2,993 / 5,049 / -40.72

Clapham 119,297 / 108,106 / 10.35

Durning 58,330 / 46,615 / 25.13

Minet 3,207 / 2 ,504 / 28.08

South Lambeth 63,771 / 58,456 / 9.09

Streatham 159,756 / 152,252 / 4.93

Upper Norwood 57,854 / 60,422 / -4.25*

Waterloo 16,194 / 17,891 / -9.49

West Norwood 51,615 /  42,126 / 22.53

Issues and renewals for March 2018 (March 2017 figures in brackets) show Upper Norwood had 6,927 (4,896) up by 41.4 per cent;  Carnegie had 1,054 (197)  up by 435 pc. Waterloo 1,300 (1,399) minus 7.08.

*Upper Norwood closed for refurbishment from 20 March

Further reading: Community groups endorse Labour’s approach to libraries Posted by LAMBETH LABOUR 10pc on April 03, 2018 (National Labour party website): “Despite these cuts, in Lambeth we’ve kept all 10 of our libraries open and last year issued more items in our libraries than ever before.”

Advertisements

One thought on “….AND HOW LAMBETH LABOUR LITERALLY COOKED THE BOOKS

  1. Just to remind everyone: Carnegie Library was CLOSED from 31 March 2016 to mid-February 2018, since when it has been PARTIALLY reopened. Minet was closed 31 March 2016 to summer 2017 then partially reopened. Waterloo & Upper Norwood considerably shrunk and de-staffed. That should put the quoted figures into context and also explode the continuing false claim that Lambeth “kept 10 libraries open”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.